Help! My DIY Beauty Gummies Turned Out Like Rubber!

SugarRushSue88August 16, 2026
S
SugarRushSue88
Aug 16, 2026, 07:00 PM

Hey everyone! So I tried making my own beauty gummies at home using gelatin and some collagen + vitamin C powder. I followed a recipe I found online, but they came out super chewy and rubbery, not like the store-bought ones. Anyone have tips on how to get that soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture? Also, should I use agar instead of gelatin? I'm new to this!

C
CrystalCathy659
Aug 16, 2026, 07:23 PM

Hey! I'm a paleo dieter, so I only use gelatin (grass-fed, of course). The rubberiness usually comes from using too much gelatin or not enough liquid. For softer gummies, try reducing the gelatin by about 25% and increase the liquid slightly. Also, make sure you're blooming the gelatin in cold water first. Another trick is to add a little bit of fruit juice with natural enzymes (like pineapple or papaya) – but careful, they can break down the gelatin and make them too soft. Oh, and you need to let them set in the fridge for at least 4 hours, not just 2!

U
UrbanUma336
Aug 16, 2026, 10:06 PM

Ooh, I've been there! The taste is a big deal for me. If they taste too bland or powdery, try using flavored electrolytes or a splash of lemon juice. But for texture, I found that using a mix of gelatin and agar (half and half) gives a nice bounce without being rubbery. And make sure you're heating the mixture gently – if you boil it too hard, it can mess up the texture. Also, adding a bit of honey or maple syrup helps not only flavor but also softens them. And don't forget to oil your molds lightly so they come out easy!

C
CrystalCathy487
Aug 17, 2026, 12:24 AM

I'm a grandparent, so I'm always cautious about what I give my grandchildren. I tried making these for my grandkids, but I was worried about the vitamin powders - some can be quite strong and the dosage is hard to control. If you're adding vitamins, make sure you're not giving them too much. Also, I found that using fruit purees (like strawberry or orange) instead of water helps mask the vitamin taste and makes them more natural. But for the rubbery issue, I'd agree - less gelatin and more liquid. And please, always check with a doctor for children's dosage!

G
GreenGreg877
Aug 16, 2026, 09:12 PM

Hey, welcome to the DIY gummy club! I've been making my own for a while now, and I've got to say, the best tip I can give is to use a kitchen thermometer. The temperature is crucial - if you don't heat the gelatin mixture enough, it won't set properly, but if you overheat, you get that rubbery mess. I aim for about 180°F (82°C) - just before it simmers. Also, I like to add a little bit of vitamin E oil as a preservative. And for a fun twist, try using a silicone mold with interesting shapes - my kids love the dinosaur ones! Keep experimenting, you'll get it right!