DIY Gummy Troubles: Why Are My Gummies So Rubbery?

KaleKen347August 15, 2026
K
KaleKen347
Aug 15, 2026, 03:00 PM

So I tried making my own gummies with gelatin and vitamin C powder. They set, but they're like chewing on rubber bands! Any tips? I used 2 tbsp gelatin per cup of liquid, maybe too much?

S
SolarSam888
Aug 15, 2026, 04:02 PM

Hey KaleKen, 2 tbsp per cup is a bit heavy. I usually go with 1 tbsp per cup for a softer chew. Also, make sure you're blooming the gelatin in cold water first, then heating slowly. And if you're using agar, different story! What kind did you use?

U
UrbanUma502
Aug 15, 2026, 07:28 PM

I've had that before! Also check if you're adding the vitamin powder too hot - can mess with the gelatin. Let the mixture cool a bit before pouring. And try adding a little honey or agave for better texture. My last batch came out great with that.

S
SolarSam
Aug 15, 2026, 04:36 PM

Oh, reminds me of my grandma's gummy recipe from the 70s. She used fruit juice and agar. But she always said 'low heat, patience, and a bit of love.' Try lowering the heat and letting it simmer slowly. Also, don't forget to whisk constantly to avoid clumps!

K
KaleKen347
Aug 15, 2026, 08:36 PM

Thanks all! I'll try the 1 tbsp per cup and lower heat. Maybe I was too eager to get them set. Appreciate the tips. Will update with results!