Magnesium Gummies on sale at Costco - too good to be true?

OPJanuary 23, 2026
O
OP
Jan 23, 2026, 08:00 AM

Hey everyone, just spotted Nature's Way Magnesium gummies at Costco for like half the price I usually pay at Whole Foods. They're 120 count for $15.99. Is this a legit steal or should I be worried about quality? I've heard cheaper supplements sometimes skimp on bioavailability or have fillers. Anyone tried these?

E
EarthElias370
Jan 23, 2026, 09:48 AM

I keep it simple - check the label. If the ingredients match your usual brand (magnesium citrate/glycinate, no artificial junk), it's probably fine. Costco often has good bulk deals on basics. I'd buy them if the mg per serving is clear and it fits my minimalist approach - fewer ingredients = better.

E
EarthElias975
Jan 23, 2026, 10:10 AM

Bro, I've been using those exact gummies from Costco for months. No issues - still hitting PRs at the gym and recovery is solid. Price doesn't always mean quality; sometimes you're just paying for marketing. As long as the magnesium source is good (these use citrate), it's a win. The 120 count lasts me forever too.

Z
ZestZack288
Jan 23, 2026, 02:18 PM

Hmm, I'd be cautious. Many gummies have sugar alcohols or additives that don't align with paleo principles. What's the sweetener? If it's stevia or monk fruit and no weird binders, might be okay for a treat. Personally, I stick to powder forms for purity, but if you're not strict paleo, the Costco deal could work.

O
OP
Jan 23, 2026, 01:28 PM

Thanks all! Checked the label - it's magnesium citrate, stevia-sweetened, no artificial colors. Sounds like it's worth a shot. EarthElias975, good to hear they work for recovery. Gonna grab a bottle and see how it goes. Appreciate the insights!