Best flavor of melatonin gummies? I'm split between strawberry and orange!

KetoKevinJuly 25, 2026
K
KetoKevin
Jul 25, 2026, 08:07 AM

I bought the mixed berry pack and holy crap the strawberry ones are amazing but the orange ones taste like medicine. Anyone else have a fave? I wanna buy a big bottle of just one flavor next time.

N
NatureNancy230
Jul 25, 2026, 09:37 AM

Ugh, I feel you! The orange ones are def not my jam either. I swear by the cherry flavor from this one brand that uses organic tapioca syrup. No artificial junk. But yeah, avoid orange like the plague lol.

T
TeaTina664
Jul 25, 2026, 11:49 AM

As a home cook, I've noticed that strawberry pairs well with the natural tartness of melatonin. Have you tried a brand that uses real fruit juice? The ones I got from Sleepy Bear are strawberry only and they're bomb. Maybe stick with strawberry!

H
HolisticHolly949
Jul 25, 2026, 12:40 PM

Wait, do you all actually think the flavor matters that much? I give my kids the raspberry ones and they don't complain. But I'm more concerned about sourcing and sugar content. Are any of these actually healthy? Also, anyone else find that orange tastes like cough syrup?

K
KetoKevin
Jul 25, 2026, 11:59 AM

Haha glad I'm not alone on the orange. I'll try the strawberry ones next. Thanks for the recs! And Holly, I feel you on the sugar, I only buy the sugar-free ones from KetoGummy. They have a lemon flavor that's not bad.