DIY Multivitamin Gummies - My batch turned into a sticky mess! Help?

GreenGreg567January 16, 2026
G
GreenGreg567
Jan 16, 2026, 06:19 PM

Hey everyone, I tried making my own multivitamin gummies at home to save some cash and control the ingredients. Used gelatin, some fruit juice, and a powdered multivitamin mix I bought online. But they came out super sticky and wouldn't set properly - just a gooey blob! Anyone have a foolproof recipe or tips on ratios? Maybe I used too much liquid? Also, does the type of vitamin powder affect gelling? Thanks!

V
VitalVince388
Jan 16, 2026, 07:10 PM

Honestly, why bother? Store-bought gummies are tested for stability and dosage accuracy. Homemade ones are risky - you might not get even vitamin distribution, and who knows if the heat from melting gelatin destroys the nutrients? Plus, sticky batches often mean wrong gelatin-to-liquid ratio or not enough setting time. But if you insist, maybe try agar instead? Heard it sets firmer. Still skeptical about the whole DIY supplement thing though.

R
RhinoRich
Jan 16, 2026, 10:19 PM

Awesome project, GreenGreg! I've been making my own for months - early adopter here! For sticky issues: use 1 tbsp gelatin per 1/2 cup liquid max, and dissolve the vitamin powder COMPLETELY in warm liquid before adding gelatin. Some powders (like iron) can interfere with gelling. Pro tip: add a tsp of citric acid for tanginess and preservation! My recipe: blueberry juice, gelatin, my custom vitamin blend, and a dash of honey. Sets perfect in silicone molds overnight. Keep experimenting!

G
GreenGreg567
Jan 17, 2026, 01:01 AM

Thanks both! Vince, I get the concern, but I'm using a reputable powder and trying to avoid fillers. Rich, that ratio helps - I think I used too much juice. Do you heat the mixture after adding vitamins, or keep it low temp? Also, any mold recommendations? Mine were kinda bland tasting lol.

V
VitalVince388
Jan 16, 2026, 08:51 PM

If you're determined, at least get a kitchen scale for precise measurements. And maybe test a small batch without vitamins first to nail the gelling. But seriously, consider just buying a quality brand - the convenience and safety might be worth the price. No offense to DIYers, but supplements aren't like baking cookies.