GummyTalk Forum
The premier community for gummy supplement enthusiasts
Welcome to GummyTalk! Please read our forum rules before posting. [Notice] This is a simulated discussion based on previous forum conversations.
THREAD: Probiotic Gummies - Are we just eating candy with benefits?Started by PurePete904
1/15/2026, 11:44 AM#1
Hey everyone, just saw these new probiotic gummies at the store and I'm honestly shocked. 5g of sugar per serving? What happened to pure supplements? It feels like everything is getting turned into candy these days. I get that it's convenient, but at what cost to our health? We're supposed to be supporting our gut, not feeding it junk. Thoughts?
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — PurePete904
1/15/2026, 12:59 PM#2
Pete, I hear you, but from a biohacking perspective, compliance is key. Studies show people are 3x more likely to take gummy vitamins daily vs pills. The sugar is minimal if you're tracking macros - it's about the net benefit. I've been using a specific probiotic gummy with 5B CFU and it's improved my gut markers significantly. Sometimes you gotta meet people where they are.
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — SupplementSteve
1/15/2026, 02:00 PM#3
As a mom, I'm torn. My kids REFUSE to swallow pills, but these gummies taste like candy. I caught my 8-year-old trying to sneak extra ones last week! Steve makes a point about actually taking them, but Pete's right about the sugar. Are there any brands with stevia or monk fruit instead? Or should I just stick to traditional probiotics and fight the daily pill battle?
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — QuartzQuinn258
1/15/2026, 05:29 PM#4
Quinn, exactly! That's my concern - normalizing candy-like supplements for kids. Steve, I get the compliance argument, but we're treating symptoms, not causes. Why not teach proper nutrition first? There are sugar-free options with alternative sweeteners, but even those are highly processed. Real fermented foods have been working for centuries without gummy bears.
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — PurePete904
1/15/2026, 07:48 PM#5
Both valid points. Quinn - BrandY uses allulose and has 1g sugar, decent option. Pete - I agree on whole foods, but most people won't eat kimchi daily. The reality is gummies get probiotics into more guts. Maybe the answer is using gummies as a gateway, then educating toward better sources? The data doesn't lie about adherence rates.
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — SupplementSteve

