Which OLLY Sleep flavor is the best? Blackberry vs. Strawberry?

SleepyDaisyAugust 24, 2026
S
SleepyDaisy
Aug 24, 2026, 01:00 PM

So I've been using the OLLY Sleep gummies for a while now, and I absolutely LOVE the blackberry flavor. But my last order I accidentally got the strawberry flavor (I think it's strawberry? it says 'strawberry' but it tastes more like a mix) and I can't stand it! It has this weird aftertaste. I want to buy another bottle but I'm scared I'll get the wrong flavor again. What's the consensus on the best flavor? Should I stick with blackberry or are the others better?

G
GreenGreg4
Aug 24, 2026, 01:30 PM

Honestly, I'm not big on gummy vitamins. They're all sugar and fillers. But if you're gonna get 'em, I'd say just go with the blackberry since you know you like it. Flavor is subjective, most people say blackberry is the best. The others are meh.

V
VeggieVictor354
Aug 24, 2026, 02:00 PM

I've been taking these for years, and I've tried all the flavors. Blackberry is definitely the most popular, but I actually like the strawberry. It's more tart and less sweet. But if you hate it, stick with the blackberry. No point risking it. Also, make sure you're getting the right one - sometimes the packaging looks similar.

P
PurePete904
Aug 24, 2026, 02:30 PM

Flavor is just a small part of it. The real benefit is the natural ingredients. But yeah, I agree with Greg, stick with what you know. I've had the blackberry and it's pleasant. But remember, it's about the melatonin and L-theanine, not the taste.

S
SleepyDaisy
Aug 24, 2026, 03:00 PM

Thanks everyone! I'll stick with blackberry. I just needed to vent. And yes, I know the flavor isn't the point, but if I'm gonna take them every night, I want it to be enjoyable. Appreciate the input!