Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies vs Natures Craft Cleansing Herbal Liver Detox Gummies Liver Support Milk Thistle Gummies with Artichoke Extract Turmeric Curcumin and L-Carnitine: Which is Better? (2025 Review)

Introduction

The world of dietary supplements has evolved dramatically, moving beyond pills and powders to more palatable and convenient formats. Gummy supplements have surged in popularity, offering a tasty alternative for those who struggle with swallowing capsules or dislike the gritty texture of powdered greens. Within this category, "supergreens" products aim to deliver concentrated [[[nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) from a blend of vegetables, grasses, and other plant-based ingredients, often targeting overall wellness and immunity.

Today, we're placing two distinct gummy supplements under the microscope. While both fall under the broad wellness umbrella, they are formulated with very different primary goals. On one side, we have Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies, a product focused on delivering a daily dose of green superfoods. On the other, we have Natures Craft Cleansing Herbal Liver Detox Gummies, a specialized formula designed for liver support and detoxification using a suite of targeted herbs and compounds. This comprehensive review will dissect each product based solely on the provided specifications, helping you determine which gummy aligns best with your specific health and lifestyle objectives.

At a Glance

Before diving into the details, here’s a quick snapshot of the fundamental differences between these two products:

• Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies: A general wellness supplement. Its formula centers on whole-food ingredients like spinach, broccoli, and moringa to provide a broad spectrum of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. It's positioned as a daily green boost for immunity support, offered at a lower price point.
• Natures Craft Liver Detox Gummies: A targeted, organ-specific supplement. Its formula is built around recognized hepatoprotective (liver-protecting) ingredients like milk thistle, artichoke extract, and turmeric. It carries certifications for being Vegan and Non-GMO and is priced at a premium.

In essence, the choice boils down to a broad-spectrum daily nutritional boost versus a focused herbal formula for liver health.

Deep Dive into Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies

Daily Green Superfoods Supplement with Spinach, Broccoli, Moringa, Beet Root, Celery, Green Tea, & Acai for Immunity Support - Natural Raspberry Flavor, 60 cnt

Product Overview

Priced at $15.97, Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies are positioned as an accessible entry into the world of green supplements. The product name highlights a classic supergreens profile, combining common vegetables with potent superfoods. The promise is one of convenience—getting the nutritional benefits of greens like spinach and broccoli in a sweet, raspberry-flavored gummy without the need for juicing or blending.

Formula & Key Ingredients Analysis (Based on Provided Data)

The ingredient list reads like a grocery list of nutrient-dense plants:

• Spinach & Broccoli: Foundation vegetables rich in vitamins A, C, K, folate, iron, and fiber.
• Moringa: Often called the "drumstick tree," its leaves are packed with vitamins, minerals, and all essential amino acids.
• Beet Root: Known for its nitrate content (which may support blood flow) and antioxidants like betalains.
• Celery: A source of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants like apigenin.
• Green Tea: Provides catechins, a class of antioxidants with widespread research on their health benefits.
• Acai: A berry celebrated for its high antioxidant content, particularly anthocyanins.

This blend suggests a focus on antioxidant support, general nutrient replenishment, and overall immune system bolstering through a diverse array of plant compounds.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Cost-Effective: At $15.97, it is significantly more affordable than many competitors in the gummy supplement space.
• Broad Ingredient Profile: Incorporates a wide range of well-known vegetables and superfoods, aiming for comprehensive nutritional support.
• Palatable Format: The natural raspberry flavor offers a pleasant alternative to powders or capsules, potentially improving consistency of use.
• Immunity Focus: The combination of ingredients like acai, green tea, and leafy greens is traditionally associated with supporting the body's natural defense systems.

Cons:

• Lack of Certifications: Based on the provided specs, it is not Vegan, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Sugar-Free, or Organic. This may be a significant drawback for consumers with specific dietary preferences or restrictions.
• Generalized Formula: While excellent for overall wellness, it lacks the targeted, high-potency herbal actives found in specialized supplements.
• Undisclosed Count per Serving: The "60 cnt" indicates 60 gummies total, but the serving size (how many gummies constitute one serving) is not specified in the data, making precise value and dosage analysis difficult.

Ideal User Profile

This product is ideal for someone new to supplements or looking for a simple, affordable, and tasty way to add more plant-based nutrients to their daily routine. It suits individuals seeking general wellness and immunity support without needing specific dietary certifications or targeted organ support.

Deep Dive into Natures Craft Cleansing Herbal Liver Detox Gummies

Liver Support Milk Thistle Gummies with Artichoke Extract Turmeric Curcumin and L-Carnitine - Vegan and Non-GMO - Sweet Lemon (45 Servings)

Product Overview

Priced at $31.99, Natures Craft Liver Detox Gummies occupy a more specialized niche. The name and ingredient list clearly signal a focus on hepatic (liver) function and detoxification support. This is not a general multivitamin or greens blend; it's a formulated combination of herbs and compounds with established reputations in traditional and modern wellness practices for supporting liver health.

Formula & Key Ingredients Analysis (Based on Provided Data)

The formula is a curated selection of liver-centric ingredients:

• Milk Thistle: The cornerstone of liver supplements. Its active compound, silymarin, is extensively studied for its antioxidant and protective effects on liver cells.
• Artichoke Extract: Contains cynarin, which is believed to support bile production and flow, aiding digestion and liver function.
• Turmeric Curcumin: The active component of turmeric is a potent anti-inflammatory and antioxidant agent, often used to support overall organ health, including the liver.
• L-Carnitine: An amino acid derivative that plays a crucial role in energy production by transporting fatty acids into mitochondria. In the context of liver health, it may support metabolic processes.

This blend suggests a focused approach on supporting the liver's natural detoxification pathways, protecting liver cells from damage, and promoting healthy metabolic function.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Targeted, Potent Formula: Features a clinically recognized lineup of ingredients specifically chosen for liver support.
• Strong Dietary Credentials: Certified as Vegan and Non-GMO, appealing to a growing segment of health-conscious consumers.
• Clear Serving Information: "45 Servings" provides immediate clarity on how long the bottle will last, assuming a standard serving-per-day regimen.
• Specialized Health Focus: Directly addresses a specific health concern (liver function/detox support), which general supergreens products do not.

Cons:

• Higher Price Point: At $31.99, it is roughly double the cost of the Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) gummies.
• Narrow Scope: Its benefits are primarily focused on liver health. It does not provide the broad-spectrum vegetable and superfruit [[[nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) of a true "supergreens" product.
• Specific Use Case: May not be necessary or desired by individuals simply looking for a daily nutritional top-up without specific liver concerns.

Ideal User Profile

This product is ideal for individuals specifically interested in supporting their liver health. This could include those concerned about environmental toxins, those who occasionally consume alcohol, or anyone seeking the purported cleansing benefits of herbs like milk thistle and artichoke. It's also a strong fit for consumers who prioritize Vegan and Non-GMO certifications in their supplements.

Head-to-Head [Comparison](/supergreens/greens-gummies-vs-powder)

Price & Value

• Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies): $15.97 for 60 gummies. The exceptional value is its most striking feature. However, without knowing the serving size (e.g., 1 or 2 gummies per serving), the true cost per serving cannot be calculated.
• Natures Craft: $31.99 for 45 servings. The price is higher, but the value is clear and quantifiable—you are paying for a specialized herbal formula with clear serving information. The cost per serving is approximately $0.71.

Verdict: Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) wins on upfront, low cost. Natures Craft wins on price transparency and defined value per serving, though at a higher overall price.

Dietary & Lifestyle Features

This is a area of stark contrast.

• Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies): The provided specs indicate it is not vegan, non-GMO, gluten-free, sugar-free, or organic. This suggests it may contain gelatin (animal-derived), genetically modified ingredients, gluten, sugar, and conventionally farmed components.
• Natures Craft: Explicitly labeled as Vegan and Non-GMO. This is a significant advantage for consumers who follow a plant-based lifestyle or wish to avoid genetically modified organisms.

Verdict: Natures Craft is the unambiguous winner for consumers with dietary restrictions or ethical purchasing preferences.

Primary Health Focus

• Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies): General Wellness & Immunity. Its strength is in providing a wide array of nutrients from everyday superfoods and vegetables.
• Natures Craft: Targeted Liver Support & Detoxification. Its strength is in delivering a potent, specific combination of herbs for a particular organ system.

Verdict: There is no crossover winner here. The "better" focus depends entirely on the user's goal. They are designed for different purposes.

[Comparison](/supergreens/greens-gummies-vs-powder) Table

The Winner

Declaring a single "winner" between these two products is not straightforward, as they are designed for fundamentally different purposes. Therefore, the winner is determined by your specific health objectives:

• Choose Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies if: Your primary goal is to affordably and conveniently increase your daily intake of vegetables and superfoods for overall wellness and immune support. You are not concerned with dietary certifications like Vegan or Non-GMO, and you are looking for the best possible price point in a greens gummy.

• Choose Natures Craft Cleansing Herbal Liver Detox Gummies if: You are specifically seeking to support your liver health with a targeted blend of respected herbs like milk thistle and artichoke. You require your supplements to be Vegan and Non-GMO, and you are willing to pay a premium for a specialized formula with transparent serving information.

Value-Based Winner: If we must choose based on the combination of price and meeting its stated goal, Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) Supergreens Gummies wins on sheer affordability for a daily greens product. However, this comes with the major caveat of its lack of dietary certifications.

Quality & Specificity Winner: For a consumer whose goal aligns with its function, Natures Craft Liver Detox Gummies represents a higher-quality, more specialized option with superior dietary credentials, justifying its higher cost for the right user.

FAQ Section

Q: Can I take both of these gummies together? A: While there is no inherent conflict in the provided ingredient lists, it is always recommended to consult with a healthcare professional before combining supplements. They can advise based on your personal health status and ensure you are not exceeding safe intake levels of any particular compound.

Q: Are these gummies suitable for children? A: Dietary supplements are generally formulated for adults. You should not give these to children without explicit direction from a pediatrician or qualified healthcare provider.

Q: Why is the Natures Craft product more than twice the price? A: The higher cost likely reflects several factors: the use of specific, often more expensive herbal extracts (like milk thistle and artichoke), the costs associated with obtaining Vegan and Non-GMO certifications, and the product's positioning as a targeted, premium supplement rather than a general wellness product.

Q: Which product is better for detox? A: By name and ingredient profile, the Natures Craft Liver Detox Gummies are explicitly formulated for this purpose. The term "detox" in supplements often refers to supporting the body's own natural detoxification systems, primarily the liver. The Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) gummies support overall health but are not specifically designed as a detox formula.

Q: Do these gummies need to be refrigerated? A: The provided data does not include storage instructions. Typically, gummy vitamins should be stored in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and heat to prevent melting and preserve potency. Always check the product label upon purchase for specific storage directions.

Q: I'm a vegan. Which product should I choose? A: Based on the specifications provided, only the Natures Craft Liver Detox Gummies are confirmed to be Vegan. The Atlantis [[[Nutrition](/supergreens/greens-gummies-kids)](/supergreens/super-greens-gummies-ingredients)](/supergreens/best-greens-gummies) gummies are not, which often indicates the use of gelatin (derived from animal collagen) as the gelling agent.